Skip to the page

Sharon Myers

A New England journal of party food, menus and cooking for a crowd

HomeCatering Guides

Dessert Tables and Dessert-Only Menus: Planning for a Crowd

Dessert Tables and Dessert-Only Menus: Planning for a Crowd

A dessert-only party is one of the easiest ways to entertain a lot of people well. An evening open house after a recital, a bridal shower in the afternoon, a reception after a late wedding ceremony when everyone has eaten already: in all of these, a table of good sweets with coffee does the whole job. It also lets you bake in stages over a week and set out nearly everything at once. The planning comes down to three numbers and a layout, and I have laid them out below.

How many desserts per guest

The count depends on whether dessert follows a meal or stands on its own.

Occasion Pieces per guest Notes
After a full dinner, with cake 1 slice of cake plus 1 to 2 small pieces Most people take cake and one cookie
Dessert table after a meal, no cake 2 to 3 pieces Plan smaller portions
Dessert-only party, evening 3 to 4 pieces People graze for two hours
Dessert-only afternoon party or shower 4 to 5 pieces Afternoon guests are hungrier

A "piece" is a cookie, a bar, a small square of cake, a mousse cup, a spoonful of trifle or a thin slice of pie. If you are serving big wedges of pie, count each as two.

Variety matters more than volume. Five or six kinds is plenty for 60 people. More than eight and the table starts to look like a bake sale, and you will throw away more.

Building a balanced menu

I build a dessert menu the way I would build a dinner: something rich, something fruity, something creamy, something crisp, and one thing simple enough for children and cautious eaters. Draw from these families:

  • Cake. A layer cake or sheet cake is the anchor and the thing people photograph. Chocolate, lemon, carrot or a classic white.
  • Cookies and bars. Shortbread, brownies, lemon squares, oatmeal cookies, molasses cookies. They fill gaps and travel home in napkins.
  • Trifle. Layers of cake, custard or pudding, fruit and whipped cream in a glass bowl. It looks generous and uses up cake trimmings.
  • Seasonal pies and tarts. Berry in summer, apple and pear in fall, a maple pecan pie in the colder months. Tarts slice more neatly than pies for a crowd.
  • Crisps and cobblers. Baked in a big rectangular dish and served warm or at room temperature with a spoon. The most forgiving dessert there is.
  • Mousse and puddings. A chocolate mousse set in small cups or glasses so nobody has to scoop.
  • Cheesecake. Rich, so cut it small. A small chocolate goat cheese cheesecake gives about 12 slim wedges.

Mixing make-ahead items

Most of a dessert table can be made days or weeks in advance, which is the whole point. Here is how the items sort out.

Make ahead How far Storage
Cookie dough, shaped and frozen Up to 1 month Freeze on trays, then bag; bake from frozen, adding 1 to 2 minutes
Brownies and bars Up to 1 month Freeze uncut, wrapped twice; cut while half thawed
Cake layers Up to 2 weeks Freeze wrapped; fill and frost the day before
Pie crust Up to 1 month Freeze as disks or in the pan
Cheesecake 2 to 3 days Refrigerated, or frozen up to 2 weeks
Mousse cups 1 day Refrigerated, covered
Trifle Assemble the morning of Refrigerated; the cake softens as it sits
Fruit pies and crisps Bake the day before or the morning of Room temperature; crisp topping recrisps 10 minutes at 350°F (175°C)

Leave only one or two things for the day itself. My rule is that nothing on the morning list should need the mixer.

Display

Height makes a dessert table look full with fewer pieces. Put the cake on a stand at the back, a trifle bowl on an upturned bowl or a sturdy box under the cloth, and pies and platters in front at table level. Group by type rather than by color, so people can see what each thing is.

Cut everything before it goes out. Pies into 10 or 12 thin slices, bars into small squares, cheesecake into slim wedges with a hot knife wiped between cuts. Guests hesitate to make the first cut and then take a piece far bigger than intended. Put a server or a small spatula with each item.

Hold back half of each cookie and bar in the kitchen and refill once. A table that looks picked over at 9 o'clock makes people leave.

Anything with whipped cream, custard, cream cheese or curd should not sit out longer than 2 hours. Put the trifle and mousse out in two rounds, and keep the second round refrigerated at 40°F (4°C) or below until it goes out.

Labeling for allergies

Make small folded cards for every dessert: the name, and then plainly, "contains nuts", "contains peanuts", "gluten-free" or "made with alcohol". Nuts are the big one on a dessert table. If you are serving a nut dessert, set it at one end with its own server, and bake it last so you are not sending nut crumbs through the rest of the baking. If you offer something gluten-free, keep it on its own plate and away from crumbs; a flourless chocolate cake or a fruit crisp with an oat topping (made with oats labeled gluten-free) works well.

A sample dessert table for 60

An evening dessert reception after a 7 o'clock concert, guests arriving around 8:30 and staying about two hours. At 3 to 4 pieces each, I plan about 220 pieces in total.

Dessert Quantity Pieces
Chocolate layer cake with raspberry filling, 10 inch 1 cake 24 slices
Lemon squares 1 half-sheet pan, cut 6 by 10 60
Brown butter shortbread and molasses cookies 4 dozen each 96
Berry trifle 1 large bowl about 25 servings
Apple crisp 1 deep 9 by 13 inch pan 16 to 18
Chocolate mousse cups 2 batches 24
Total about 245

That gives a little margin over 220, and the cookies go home with people at the end. Add coffee (plan about 1 1/2 cups per person, so about 90 cups) and tea, with cream, milk and sugar, and a pitcher of cold water.

The baking plan runs over two weeks: cookie dough and lemon square crust frozen first, cake layers next, mousse the day before in two batches, crisp baked that afternoon, trifle built at 5 o'clock. At 8:15 the cake comes out of the refrigerator, the cards go on, and the coffee goes on to brew.

Topics: Cakes & Baking | Menus & Planning

Abigail Thurlow

Abigail bakes the cakes, pies and bread for her family's celebrations in western Massachusetts. She writes about layer cakes, crusts, quick breads and baking ahead.

More for the table