Skip to the page

Sharon Myers

A New England journal of party food, menus and cooking for a crowd

HomeSample Menus

Summer Barbecue Buffet for 85: Menu, Grill Math and Food Safety

Summer Barbecue Buffet for 85: Menu, Grill Math and Food Safety

Eighty-five people is a barbecue where the grill stops being a hobby and becomes a production line. Everything on this menu is familiar, which is the point at a summer party for a crowd: grilled sausages, hot dogs for the kids, chicken in a sticky apricot sauce, four salads that don't mind the heat, and a cobbler. The hard parts are not the recipes. They are how much your grill can actually cook in an hour, and how to keep a buffet safe when it's 88°F (31°C) in the shade.

The menu

To start

  • Guacamole with tortilla chips, salsa and sour cream

From the grill

  • Chicken and apple sausages
  • Lamb sausages with garlic and rosemary
  • Beef hot dogs
  • Grilled chicken in apricot barbecue sauce
  • Mustards, ketchup, relish, sliced onions, sauerkraut
  • Assorted rolls and breads

Salads

  • Watermelon and feta salad with mint
  • White bean and Gruyère salad with herbs
  • Summer squash salad with mint and lemon
  • Corn, tomato and potato salad in a mustard vinaigrette

Dessert

  • Blueberry cobbler with whipped cream
  • Coffee, cream and sugar, plus iced tea, lemonade and a lot of water

Quantities for 85

Item Per guest For 85
Guacamole 1/4 cup 5 1/2 quarts (about 40 avocados)
Chips 1 1/2 oz 8 lb
Salsa / sour cream 3 quarts / 2 quarts
Sausage links, both kinds 1 85 links (45 chicken apple, 40 lamb)
Beef hot dogs 1/2 45
Chicken pieces, bone-in 1 1/4 105 pieces (about 32 lb)
Rolls 1 1/2 130
Each of 4 salads 1/2 cup 11 quarts each
Blueberry cobbler 1 serving 4 full hotel pans or 6 half sheet pans
Whipped cream 2 quarts heavy cream, whipped
Ice 1 1/2 lb 130 lb (drinks plus salad beds)

The sausages are cut in half on the diagonal before they go on the platter. People take two halves of different kinds, which is exactly what you want, and the platter looks fuller than it is.

Grill capacity math

Here is where most big barbecues go wrong. A host with one gas grill looks at 105 pieces of chicken and 130 links and doesn't do the arithmetic until five o'clock.

A large backyard gas grill has about 500 square inches of main cooking surface. A 22 inch charcoal kettle has a bit over 350. A bone-in chicken thigh with room around it takes about 16 square inches; a sausage link about 10.

Food Space each Per batch, 500 sq in grill Time per batch Batches for this menu
Chicken pieces (raw to done) 16 sq in 30 40 to 45 min 4 (about 3 hours)
Chicken, oven-started, finished on grill 16 sq in 30 10 to 12 min 4 (about 45 min)
Sausages and hot dogs 10 sq in 50 12 to 15 min 3 (about 45 min)

Three hours of chicken on one grill is not a party, it's a shift. So the plan here is to start the chicken in the oven: bake it on sheet pans at 375°F (190°C) until it reaches about 150°F (66°C) inside, then finish it on the grill over medium heat with the apricot sauce, turning and basting until it's glazed and reads 165°F (74°C). That cuts grill time by three quarters. The one rule: the chicken goes from the oven straight to the grill. Never partly cook chicken and set it aside to finish later.

Better still, borrow a second grill. With two, one does chicken and one does sausages, and everything is off the fire inside an hour. If you only have one, do the sausages first (they hold well for 45 minutes in a covered foil pan inside a clean, empty cooler lined with towels, which keeps them above 140°F (60°C) while the oven is busy) and the chicken second, since it's the one guests notice when it's hot.

Fuel: a 20 lb propane tank runs a large grill for roughly 18 to 20 hours on medium, so one full tank is plenty, but bring a spare anyway. For charcoal, figure a full chimney per batch and a 20 lb bag for the afternoon.

Food safety in the heat

The usual rule is that perishable food should sit out no longer than two hours. Above 90°F (32°C), that drops to one hour. On a hot July afternoon you should plan for the one-hour rule from the start.

  • Hold cold salads at 40°F (4°C) or below by nesting each serving bowl in a larger bowl or hotel pan of crushed ice. Put out half the salad and keep the rest in the refrigerator or a cooler; refill with a fresh bowl, never by topping off the old one.
  • Guacamole goes out in small bowls on ice. It browns and warms quickly; three small refills look better than one big tired bowl.
  • Keep raw chicken and raw sausages in their own cooler, and use separate platters and tongs for raw and cooked. Label the tongs with tape if you have helpers.
  • Use an instant-read thermometer on every batch of chicken, in the thickest part of a thigh, away from the bone.
  • Hold cooked meat at 140°F (60°C) or above in covered pans on the cool side of the grill or in a low oven.
  • Set the buffet in shade. Sun on a stainless pan can heat it far faster than the air temperature suggests.

I chose the salads with this in mind. None of them is a mayonnaise salad. The corn, tomato and potato salad uses a sharp mustard vinaigrette, and the white bean salad only gets better as it sits in its dressing. There are plenty of other buffet salads on the soups and salads shelf if you want to change one out.

The day before and the day of

The day before: Make the apricot sauce. Cook the white beans (or rinse canned) and dress them. Cook and cool the potatoes. Make the cobbler fruit filling and the topping dough separately. Freeze a few gallon jugs of water: they cool the coolers and become drinking water later.

The morning of, for a 4 p.m. party:

  • 9:00: Cut watermelon and squash, cut corn from the cob, refrigerate everything separately.
  • 11:00: Assemble the cobblers in their pans and refrigerate.
  • 2:30: Light the grill. Make the guacamole.
  • 3:00: First round of chicken into the oven at 375°F (190°C). Sausages and hot dogs on the grill.
  • 3:35: Second round of chicken in. Sausages into the towel-lined cooler. Assemble the salads.
  • 4:00: Guacamole and chips out. First round of chicken from the oven straight to the grill with sauce.
  • 4:15: Second round to the grill. Cobblers into the oven at 375°F (190°C).
  • 4:45: Buffet opens.
  • 5:30: Cobbler and coffee out.

The worked example in the timeline is the chicken: 105 pieces, oven-started in four sheet pans per round, two rounds, then four grill batches of about ten minutes each. If the clock slips, the sausages can wait in their covered pan. The chicken can't, so it gets the grill last and alone, and it never waits between oven and fire.

For other crowd plans built around one cook and one grill, see the sample menus page, and the kitchen craft shelf for thermometers and coolers.

The apricot barbecue sauce

This sauce is sweet enough to glaze but sharp enough to cut through the char. It burns if the fire is too hot, so baste only in the last ten minutes.

From the recipe box

Apricot barbecue sauce for a crowd

About 5 cups, enough for 30 to 35 lb of chicken

Prep
10 min
Cook
25 min
Total
35 min
Show amounts in

Sauce

  • 2 cups640 g apricot preserves
  • 1 1/2 cups360 ml ketchup
  • 1/2 cup120 ml cider vinegar
  • 1/4 cup52 g packed brown sugar
  • 2 tbsp30 ml soy sauce
  • 2 tbsp30 ml Dijon mustard
  • 1 small1 small onion, grated
  • 44 garlic cloves, grated
  • 2 tsp10 ml smoked paprika
  • 1/2 tsp2.5 ml red pepper flakes

Method

  1. Combine everything in a heavy saucepan and stir over medium heat until the preserves melt.
  2. Bring to a gentle simmer, stirring often, since sugar on the bottom of the pan scorches fast.
  3. Simmer 20 minutes, until the sauce is glossy and thick enough to coat a spoon.
  4. Taste and adjust with more vinegar for sharpness or a pinch of salt.
  5. Purée with a stick blender if you want it smooth for basting.
  6. Cool, then refrigerate in jars for up to 5 days.
  7. Set aside 1 1/2 cups in a clean bowl for serving; the rest is for basting raw or partly cooked chicken and should not go to the table.

Notes from the kitchen

  • Warm the sauce before basting so it spreads thinly and doesn't cool the chicken.
  • Baste only after the chicken is nearly done; the sugar blackens in a few minutes over a hot fire.

The cobbler comes out of the oven while the buffet line is still moving, deep purple and bubbling at the edges. Leave it to cool on the counter for 20 minutes so the juices thicken, and put the whipped cream out in a bowl set in ice, because at 5:30 on a July afternoon it will not wait for you.

Topics: Menus & Planning | Main Dishes

Wes Kittredge

Wes grew up on the New Hampshire side of the river and does most of his cooking over a grill or in a big roasting pan. He writes about main dishes, fish and feeding a crowd outdoors.

More for the table