Italian Christmas Dinner for 35: Buffet Menu and Make-Ahead Plan

Thirty-five people at Christmas is the size where a sit-down dinner stops making sense and a buffet starts paying for itself. This menu leans Italian because almost all of it can be made before the doorbell rings: the antipasto is assembled, not cooked, the lasagna bakes from the refrigerator, the salads are cut that afternoon and the dessert is better on its second day. The only thing that needs a cook at the stove during the party is the chard, and it takes ten minutes. It follows the same pattern as the other crowd plans on the sample menus page: cook early, assemble late. More of those plans sit on the menus and planning shelf.
The menu
Antipasto table
- Assorted cured meats and Italian-style cheeses
- Marinated vegetables: peppers, mushrooms, artichoke hearts
- Breadsticks and a sweet grape bread
- Mixed olives
- Artichoke and chestnut pâté with plain water crackers
Buffet
- Vegetarian lasagna with spinach, mushrooms and three cheeses
- Caesar salad
- Orange, fennel and black olive salad
- Sautéed Swiss chard with garlic, golden raisins and pine nuts
- Assorted breads with seasoned dipping oil
Dessert
- Italian ricotta pie with candied citron and chocolate
- Coffee and tea
Why it works for a crowd
The antipasto table does two jobs. It feeds people during the first hour, while coats are still coming off, and it covers the meat eaters so the main dish can be vegetarian without anyone feeling shorted. A vegetarian lasagna also solves the question of the one cousin who doesn't eat meat, and it reheats more forgivingly than a meat sauce version.
The two salads are deliberately different. Caesar is rich and familiar; the orange and fennel salad is sharp, cold and bright, which is what you want next to a pan of baked cheese. The chard is the only warm vegetable, and its sweetness from the raisins ties it to the dessert.
How many lasagna pans for 35
This is the question everybody asks, so here is the arithmetic. A 9 by 13 inch pan, three layers deep, cuts into 12 generous squares. On a buffet with a full antipasto table and three sides, most guests take one square and about a third come back for a smaller second.
| Item | Per guest | For 35 |
|---|---|---|
| Lasagna squares (9 x 13 pan cut 12) | 1.3 | 4 pans (48 squares) |
| Cured meats | 2 oz | 4 1/2 lb |
| Cheeses | 1 1/2 oz | 3 1/2 lb |
| Marinated vegetables | 1/3 cup | 3 quarts |
| Olives | 2 tbsp | 2 quarts |
| Breadsticks | 2 | 70 |
| Romaine for Caesar | 1/6 head | 6 large heads |
| Navel oranges / fennel bulbs | 10 oranges, 4 bulbs | |
| Swiss chard (raw) | 4 oz | 9 lb (about 10 bunches) |
| Bread for dipping | 1 1/2 oz | 4 to 5 loaves, 2 cups oil |
| Ricotta pie | 1 slice | 4 pies, cut 10 each |
Four pans leaves you a little over, which is the right side to err on at Christmas. If you only own deep hotel pans (the half-size steam table kind), three of them do the work of four 9 by 13 pans, but they need 20 more minutes in the oven.
Check your oven before you buy the noodles. Most home ovens fit two 9 by 13 pans per rack only if the pans have no handles sticking out. Measure with the empty pans. If you can only fit three, bake the fourth in a neighbor's oven or bake in two rounds, 30 minutes apart, so the second round comes out just as the first is being served.
The make-ahead plan
Three days before. Make the artichoke and chestnut pâté (canned artichoke hearts, roasted peeled chestnuts, garlic, olive oil, lemon, a little Parmesan, all pulsed until spreadable). It improves overnight. Marinate the vegetables. Make the dipping oil with garlic, red pepper flakes, rosemary and dried oregano, and keep it in the refrigerator, since garlic in oil should never sit at room temperature for days.
Two days before. Bake the ricotta pies. They need a full night in the refrigerator anyway to set firm enough for clean slices. Make the Caesar dressing; use pasteurized eggs or a mayonnaise base for a crowd this size.
The day before. Assemble the four lasagnas, cover them tightly and refrigerate. Wash and dry the romaine and roll it in towels in bags. Blanch the chard stems and leaves separately, squeeze them dry and refrigerate them in a bowl. Toast the pine nuts. Set out every platter and serving spoon with a sticky note saying what goes on it.
The day of, for a 6 p.m. dinner.
- 3:00: Slice the meats and cheeses and arrange the antipasto platters. Cover and refrigerate.
- 3:30: Segment the oranges and slice the fennel thin. Dress them with olive oil, lemon and salt just before guests arrive.
- 4:00: Take the lasagnas out of the refrigerator.
- 4:30: Heat the oven to 375°F (190°C).
- 4:45: Lasagnas in, covered with foil.
- 5:15: Antipasto out as guests arrive.
- 5:45: Uncover the lasagnas and rotate the pans.
- 6:05: Lasagnas out. Rest 20 minutes; they cut cleanly only after resting.
- 6:15: Sauté the chard in two batches, toss the Caesar, slice the bread. Dinner on.
A cold lasagna straight from the refrigerator takes about an hour covered and 20 to 25 minutes uncovered. The center should read 165°F (74°C) and the edges should bubble. If the top browns before the center is hot, lay the foil back on loosely.
The chard, at the stove
This is the one warm-from-the-pan dish, and it is worth doing at the last minute. In your widest skillet, warm a good film of olive oil with sliced garlic until the garlic is pale gold. Add the chopped blanched stems first, then the leaves, a handful of golden raisins plumped in hot water, and salt. Toss for three or four minutes until everything is hot and glossy, then finish with the pine nuts and a squeeze of lemon. Two batches in a 12 inch pan covers 35 people. Hold it in a covered dish on the buffet; it is good warm or at room temperature, which is the beauty of it.
Service style
Run the antipasto table on its own, away from the main buffet, so people graze there while the lasagna finishes. When dinner goes out, set the buffet so plates come first, then the salads, then the lasagna, chard and bread at the end. Put someone at the lasagna with a square spatula: guests cutting their own pieces from a hot pan leave you with rubble by the third pan.
With 35 guests, about the outer edge of what I'd run from a home kitchen without hired help, one line works if the table is open on both sides. Set duplicate tongs and spoons on each side and the line moves twice as fast.
Swaps and dietary notes
- Gluten-free guests can eat from the antipasto table (keep a separate plate of crackers labeled), both salads if you serve the croutons on the side, and the chard. Bake one small gluten-free lasagna in an 8 inch square pan if you know they are coming.
- Label the pâté and the chard for nuts, since both contain them.
- For guests who want meat in the main course, add a pan of sausage and peppers; it bakes alongside the lasagna at the same temperature.
- If fennel is poor at the market, a winter salad of bitter greens with pears works in its place, like the greens with pears, Asiago and cashews.
The ricotta pie
Make four of these. The crust is a sweet, cookie-like pastry, the filling is drained ricotta lightened with eggs, and the citron and chocolate are what make it a Christmas pie rather than a cheesecake.
From the recipe box
Italian ricotta pie with citron and chocolate
One 9-inch pie, 10 slices
- Prep
- 40 min
- Cook
- 1 hr
- Rest
- 8 hr
- Total
- 9 hr 40 min
Sweet crust
- 2 cups250 g all-purpose flour
- 1/2 cup100 g sugar
- 1 tsp5 ml baking powder
- 1 stick113 g cold unsalted butter, cubed
- 1 large1 large egg plus 1 yolk
- 1 tsp5 ml finely grated lemon zest
Filling
- 2 lb900 g whole-milk ricotta, drained overnight
- 3/4 cup150 g sugar
- 3 large3 large eggs
- 1 tsp5 ml vanilla extract
- 1 tsp5 ml finely grated orange zest
- 1/3 cup55 g candied citron, finely diced
- 3 oz85 g bittersweet chocolate, chopped small
- 1/4 tsp1 ml ground cinnamon
Method
- Pulse the flour, sugar and baking powder in a food processor, add the butter and pulse until it looks like coarse meal.
- Add the egg, yolk and lemon zest and pulse just until the dough clumps; press it into a disk, wrap and chill 30 minutes.
- Heat the oven to 350°F (175°C) with a rack in the lower third.
- Roll two thirds of the dough to an 11-inch round and fit it into a 9-inch deep pie plate; chill while you mix the filling.
- Beat the drained ricotta and sugar until smooth, then beat in the eggs one at a time, the vanilla, orange zest and cinnamon.
- Fold in the citron and chocolate and pour the filling into the crust.
- Roll the remaining dough, cut it into strips and lay a lattice over the top, pressing the ends into the edge.
- Bake 55 to 65 minutes, until the crust is golden, the edge of the filling is set and the center wobbles only slightly when you nudge the plate.
- Cool completely on a rack, then refrigerate at least 8 hours before slicing with a knife dipped in hot water.
Notes from the kitchen
- Drain the ricotta in a sieve lined with cheesecloth over a bowl overnight; wet ricotta makes a weepy pie.
- The pies keep 3 days covered in the refrigerator. Bake all four on two racks and swap them halfway through.
Bring the pies out of the refrigerator half an hour before dessert so the chocolate isn't hard as gravel, and cut them at the table: ten slices each, forty in all, and the last slice is usually gone before the coffee is.
Topics: Menus & Planning | Main Dishes

Wes grew up on the New Hampshire side of the river and does most of his cooking over a grill or in a big roasting pan. He writes about main dishes, fish and feeding a crowd outdoors.


